and transportation project
“With recent changes in water and fuel availability, energy production and regulation, and community interaction, the previously omitted interdependencies between critical infrastructure systems in the United States are not as negligible as they once were,” the Principal Investigators said. “This project focuses on developing an analytical framework for modeling and analyzing these Interdependent Critical Infrastructure (ICI) systems, incorporating both renewable energy and national transportation systems.”
The results will be used to create a wealth of knowledge that will drive future energy and environmental policies, infrastructure design and management, and educational curricula.
- Paper on Optimal Electric Vehicle Choice
- Team to Bolster ICI Project with $2.43M NSF Grant for New Study
- Team Publishes Paper on Seasonal Water-Power Grid Relationships
- Summer 2017 Progress Update
- Summer 2016 Progress Update
In January 2018, ICI team members published a paper in the International Journal of Energy Research exploring the complex answer to a seemingly simple question: What type of electric vehicle — hybrid-electric, plugin hybrid or battery powered all-electric — best balances environmental and consumer needs?
Transitioning from petroleum-fueled passenger vehicles to renewably powered ones is a widely acclaimed tactic for cutting greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, but putting it into practice has been slow. While electric vehicles are gaining popularity, they make up a small proportion of cars on the road because their purchase and maintenance costs are high and yet their effective driving range remains low.
Attempts by manufacturers to increase the driving range with more battery storage unfortunately also increases price. Cars capable of using both electric and petroleum fuel sources solve the range problem — but also have higher emissions.
So, what’s the best option?
Tracing the emissions and costs of vehicle construction, purchase, and operation — and the emissions and costs of their possible fuel sources — ICI team members built an optimization model to analyze and rank vehicles given a certain annual range of miles driven. All the inputs they looked at are visualized in Figure 1.
The results can be briefly highlighted as follows:
- Generally, when cost reduction is the biggest concern, a hybrid-electric vehicle is usually best — especially when annual miles traveled are high.
- When GHG emission reduction is most important, a plugin hybrid electric vehicle is the optimal solution over a wide range of annual mileage.
- At low annual travel range, all-electric vehicles are the best economic option.
- And, finally, as our electricity sources become cleaner — more wind, solar, and nuclear sources instead of coal — all-electric vehicles are the preferred environmental choice.
“Although there are studies on the environmental impacts of (electric vehicles), the optimal selection of these vehicles when several parameters vary has not been deeply investigated,” wrote iSEE Postdoctoral Research Associate Pouria Ahmadi, a co-author of the study along with Primary Investigators Ximing Cai and Madhu Khanna. “We aimed to comprehensively model and compare different vehicles to find the tradeoffs and tipping points in consumer choices.”
The team’s full methodology and detailed results can be viewed in the full publication >>>
AUG. 17, 2017 — To help explore particular aspects of the Critical Infrastructure and Transportation project that hit close to home in Illinois, Principal Investigator Ximing Cai and others were awarded $2.43 million from the National Science Foundation (NSF) for a study titled “Advancing FEW System Resilience in the Corn Belt by Integrated Technology-Environment-Economics Modeling of Nutrient Cycling.”
Funded by this award through the NSF Innovations at the Nexus of Food, Energy and Water Systems (INFEWS) initiative, Cai will work with Roland Cusick, Assistant Professor of Civil and Environmental Engineering; Benjamin Gramig, Associate Professor of Agricultural and Consumer Economics; Vijay Singh, Professor of Agricultural and Biological Engineering and the Director of the Integrated Bioprocessing Research Laboratory; and Gregory McIsaac, Professor Emeritus of Natural Resources and Environmental Sciences and Senior Research Scientist at the Agricultural Watershed Institute.
An overview of the newly funded study:
“Food production, water supply, water quality, energy supply, and economic growth and financial stability in the Corn Belt depend on each other while competing for resources. In particular, recent increases in corn-based ethanol production in the region have increased interdependencies among food, energy and water (FEW) in the region and made the integrated FEW system more vulnerable to risks and threats. To help decision makers in Corn Belt watersheds address such interrelated challenges and opportunities, we will develop an Integrated Technology-Environment-Economics Modeling (ITEEM) tool to be used to understand how changes in one sector may cause changes in other sectors. The ITEEM will be used to compare whether and how different approaches to addressing problems and opportunities in the integrated FEW systems, including: a) recovering nutrients from grain processing and wastewater treatment facilities; b) strategic integration of perennial grasses like Miscanthus and switchgrass into annual grain landscapes for biofuel feedstock production and nutrient and sediment loss reduction; and c) adjusting farm management practices that influence nutrient and sediment loss to surface water.”
New research published by iSEE’s Critical Infrastructure and Transportation team recommends a new way to regulate how we deal with electricity generation during times when it’s really hot and/or during an ongoing drought.
The relationship between a reliable electricity supply and the health of aquatic ecosystems is complex. When water is drawn into a power plant, it enters at one temperature but leaves a lot warmer after performing its cooling function during the power generation process. The extra heat the water carries when it rejoins its source is a form of “thermal pollution,” and it’s a big concern for ecosystem health.
“Even small increases in ambient temperature — 5-10 degrees Celsius — can have significant impacts on the health of aquatic organisms like fish,” said William Lubega, an Ph.D. Candidate in Environmental Engineering and lead author of the paper published in Applied Energy. “When you have a drought and a heat wave (at the same time), the temperature of the water is already higher than usual, and the fish are experiencing thermal stress.”
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) rules cap the amount of thermal pollution power generators can put into the environment. But when a heat wave strikes, energy demand increases as lots of AC units are switched on. At the same time, the ambient water temperatures are going up, and the streamflow is going down. The ecosystem is stressed, and yet the power plants need to make even more electricity. Because a shortfall of energy cannot be allowed, the EPA grants “variances,” or permission to pollute more than usual, to the power plants.
This usually happens retroactively, only after it is apparent extra pollution is going to happen. Plants submit requests for some leeway independently, with no communication between operators. Generally, everyone asks to keep producing at the same level, Lubega wrote, and so lots of extra pollution occurs.
Lubega’s work claims that this isn’t the best way to go about providing energy — especially since it jeopardizes the environment. He instead looked at the system as an optimization problem: How do we get all the energy we need while minimizing environmental impact?
He mathematically modeled the relationships between power plants and rivers, and between rivers and the atmosphere. The resulting computer model can receive information about a particular system of power plants and the water sources they’re relying on, then respond with best energy generation levels for each plant and the number of variances it actually needs.
“The difference in this approach is that we’re looking at the entire grid, the sum of energy we need, rather than a single power plant at a time,” he said. “To give out the smallest number of variances possible, some plants may reduce their output below usual level, and others may continue at the same level because their water source is less stressed.”
Research into the so-called “energy-water nexus” is becoming an increasingly important in the face of global climate change.
“Availability of freshwater for electricity, as well as all other uses, is likely to be highly variable as climate changes. At the same time, global energy demand continues to increase,” said paper co-author Ashlynn Stillwell, Assistant Professor of Civil and Environmental Engineering. “Our aim with this research was to create some adaptable tools that can help us balance the water and energy needs, while also preserving aquatic ecosystems.”
Lubega and Stillwell suggest that proactive optimal rules for energy generation during drought or heat wave conditions could be integrated into regular power grid seasonal planning procedures as standard practice.
“Rules developed in advance are straightforward for the relevant environmental agency to apply, and minimize uncertainty and associated financial risk for the various power system participants,” they wrote.
P.I. Ximing Cai reports the following progress during the second year of this iSEE-funded project:
- Researchers are developing optimal thermal variance rules for different hydrological and meteorological conditions with an Illinois case study — and ongoing work for the country.
- Team members are identifying multiple tradeoffs between water quantity, water quality, and biofuel development through an Illinois watersheds case study (right).
- Researchers are jointly determining demand and pricing in the coupled power grid and transportation network to minimize the social cost of electronic vehicles.
- They are also assessing costs and benefits of strategies for reducing carbon emissions, and proposing economic incentives and policies to achieve low-carbon fuel greenhouse gas reduction targets.
- And team members are selecting optimal electronic vehicle options state-by-state in the United States through life cycle analysis.
P.I. Thomas Overbye reports the following successes one year into this iSEE-funded project:
- The dependence of the electric grid on water has been analyzed, using droughts and heat waves to develop generation operating points and constraints.
- The team has quantified the tradeoffs between profitability, food and fuel production, greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and nitrate runoff reduction with different types of biofuels in the Sangamon watershed in Illinois and analyzed the optimal mix of biofuels as well as the policies that should supplement the mandate to achieve multiple environmental outcomes.
- Project researchers have modeled the load of EV charging stations in response to day-ahead electricity prices; the next step will be to incorporate EV load modeling as a demand response program into the electricity market.
- The team is continuing a study that found that on average, the total mining water used in U.S. oil/gas producing counties has increased by 62% since fracking expanded in the late 2000s; results suggest that the majority of additional water used was withdrawn from groundwater resources.
- And the team has developed a model used to examine the synergies and trade-offs generated by overlapping renewable energy policies in the transportation sector and their implications for the cost of GHG mitigation.
Principal Investigators and co-PIs (all pictured in group photo)
- Ximing Cai, Lovell Endowed Professor of Civil and Environmental Engineering (CEE). His departmental page. His Ven Te Chow Hydrosystems Lab page.
- Madhu Khanna, Professor of Agricultural and Consumer Economics (ACE). Her departmental page.
- Yanfeng Ouyang, Professor of CEE. His departmental page. His Rail Transportation and Engineering Center (RAILTEC) page. His Industrial and Enterprise Systems Engineering (ISE) page.
- Ashlynn Stillwell, Assistant Professor of CEE. Her departmental page. Her research group page. Her Ven Te Chow Hydrosystems Lab page.
Operating Team: Faculty, Scientists, Postdocs, and Students (all in group photo unless otherwise noted)
- Hadi Meidani, Assistant Professor of CEE. His departmental page. His Uncertainty Quantification Group page.
- Albert Valocchi, Professor of CEE. His departmental page. His research group page. His Ven Te Chow Hydrosystems Lab page.
- Shaowen Wang, Professor of Geography and Geographic Information Science. His departmental page. His Department of Urban & Regional Planning page. His School of Earth, Society, and the Environment (SESE) page. His National Center for Supercomputing Applications (NCSA) page. His lab page.
- Pouria Ahmadi, Postdoctoral Research Associate with iSEE. (not pictured).
- William Lubega, Ph.D. Candidate in CEE (right). His lab page. Read more about William and his work >>>
- Desiree Phillips, Ph.D. Candidate in ECE. Her departmental page.
- Majid Shafiee-Jood, Ph.D. Candidate in CEE. (not pictured). His lab page.
- Jia Zhong, Ph.D. Candidate in ACE. Her departmental page. Read more about Jia and her work >>>
- Kaiqing Zhang, M.S. Candidate in ECE. His departmental page.
Former Team Members
- Thomas Overbye, original PI, former Fox Family Professor of Electrical and Computer Engineering (ECE), now at Texas A&M University.
- Hao Zhu, former Assistant Professor of ECE, now at the University of Texas at Austin.
Publications & Presentations
(iSEE project members’ names in bold):
- Poster: “The Effect of Cooling Water Constraints on Loss of Load Probability.” Wackerman, G.; Lubega, W. N.; Stillwell, A. Power and Energy Conference at Illinois (PECI), Urbana, IL, February 2018.
- Publication: “Multicriterion optimal electric drive vehicle selection based on lifecycle emission and lifecycle cost.” Ahmadi, P.; Cai, X.; Khanna, M. International Journal of Energy Research, January 2018.
- Publication: “Maintaining Electric Grid Reliability under Hydrologic Drought and Heat Wave Conditions.” Lubega, W.N.; Stillwell, A. Applied Energy, July 2017.
- Presentation: “Going Beyond the Blend Wall: Policy Incentives for Fuel Consumers to Supplement the Renewable Fuel Standard.” Zhong, J; Khanna, M. Agricultural & Applied Economics Association Annual Meeting, Chicago, IL, 2017.
- Presentation: “Analysis of Economic Criteria in the Creation of Realistic Synthetic Power Systems.” Phillips, D.; Xu, T.; Overbye, T. Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers Power and Energy Society Powertech Conference, Manchester, UK, 2017.
- Presentation: “Maintaining Electric Grid Reliability under Drought Conditions.” Lubega, W.N. World Environmental and Water Resources Congress, West Palm Beach, FL, 2016.
- Publication: “Mix of First- and Second-Generation Biofuels to Meet Multiple Environmental Objectives: Implications for Policy at a Watershed Scale.” Housh, M.; Khanna, M.; Cai, X. Water Economics and Policy, World Scientific, 2015, doi: 10.1142/S2382624X1550006X.